Basic research. What does the housing affordability ratio show ... Methodology for calculating the indicator "The share of wastewater treated by standards in the total volume of wastewater"

	Is housing affordable for Russians?
	Worked on the theme of the issue:
	Hope KOSAREVA	Andrey TUMANOV

What does the housing affordability ratio show ...

In Russia, due to the lack of data on median incomes and median housing prices, the housing affordability coefficient in accordance with the methodology of the Federal Target Program "Housing" is calculated based on the values ​​of the following indicators: the average price of 1 sq. M. m of housing, average per capita cash income multiplied by 3 (a family of three), and a social standard of housing area corresponding to a given family size - 54 sq. m.

It is noteworthy that in 1998, before the economic crisis, a family of three had to set aside all their cash income to purchase standard housing at average prices for 4.9 years, and after the crisis - more than 7.3 years. Since 1999, this indicator has had a positive trend (Fig. 7). By 2006, the housing affordability ratio had increased and amounted to about 4.7 years. It should be recalled that the federal target program "Housing" for 2010 provides for the target value of this indicator, equal to three years.

Figure 7. Coefficient of housing affordability in Russia, 1998-2006

(the lower the coefficient, the better)

Note. 2010 - the target indicator of the Federal Target Program "Zhilishche".

A source: 1998-2006 - calculations by the Institute for Urban Economics according to Rosstat data.

Using prices in certain segments of the housing market instead of average prices, one can consider the availability of purchasing different types of housing.

The coefficient of housing affordability in the primary and secondary market, presented in Fig. 8 is calculated on the assumption that a family of three buys housing at the prices of the primary (secondary) market. It should be noted that in accordance with this indicator, housing on the secondary market is more affordable for the population than newly built housing. In 2006, the values ​​of these indicators approached.

Rice. 8. Coefficient of housing affordability in the primary and secondary markets in Russia, 1998-2006

A source:

In its economic essence, this indicator characterizes only one of the factors of housing affordability, namely, the ratio of prices in the housing market and the level of income of the population. From this point of view, the values ​​of the housing affordability coefficient that do not exceed 3-5 years are considered normal in world practice. These international boundaries of the housing affordability coefficient in 2006 corresponded to the values ​​in 45 constituent entities of the Russian Federation, of which in 4 regions, in order to acquire housing, a family of three had to save money for less than three years. In 21 regions, housing was not available, as the accumulation period is more than 5 years. In fig. 9 shows the number of constituent entities of the Russian Federation, the values ​​of the housing affordability coefficient for which fall within the specified range.

Figure 9. Distribution of 88 constituent entities of the Russian Federation by the values ​​of the housing affordability coefficient in 2006 (by the number of constituent entities)

A source: calculations of the Institute of Urban Economics according to Rosstat data.

Among the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, the best (lowest) value of the indicator was observed in the Nenets Autonomous Okrug and in the Tyumen Region, and the worst (highest) - in the Vladimir Region (Fig. 10).

Figure 10. Subjects of the Russian Federation with the highest and lowest values ​​of the housing affordability coefficient in 2006

A source: calculations of the Institute of Urban Economics according to Rosstat data.

The analysis of the housing affordability coefficient in the context of the federal districts of Russia shows the best situation in the Ural Federal District. To purchase a standard apartment, a family of three needs to use the income of 3.5 years, while a family from the Central Federal District would take 4.8 years (Fig. 11).

Figure 11. Coefficient of housing affordability by federal districts of Russia, 1998-2006

The analysis of housing affordability for various categories of the population is presented. The main indicator of the state of the housing market from the point of view of the possibility of acquiring apartments by citizens is the coefficient of housing affordability. The problem of housing affordability should be considered in the aggregate of three main components of affordability: purchasing (receiving) housing for private ownership, renting housing and paying for current (recurring) costs associated with the maintenance, repair and operation of housing. Also, due to the local nature of housing markets, high territorial differentiation of incomes of the population and the level of development of mortgage lending, the analysis of factors and indicators of housing affordability must be carried out not only and not so much in the Russian Federation as a whole, but also in the regional and municipal context.

housing affordability ratio

housing

housing affordability indicators

1. Gusev A.B. Development of a methodology for assessing the affordability of housing with a loan in Russia. Access mode: http://realtymarket.ru/docs/pps/gusev1.pdf.

2. Interfax Russia, access mode http://www.interfax-russia.ru/Ural/report.asp?id=203926.

3. The official website of the Open Joint Stock Company "Agency for Housing Mortgage Lending". Access mode: http://www.ahml.ru/ru/borrower/ipProg/standart/.

4. Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 31, 2005 No. 865 (as amended on 08.08.2007) "On additional measures to implement the federal target program" Housing "for 2002 - 2010".

5. Sternik G.M. Determination of the housing affordability coefficient. / G.M. Sternik, A.N. Krasnopolskaya. // Monthly independent magazine "National Projects", 2007. No. 3 (10). Access mode: http://www.rus-reform.ru/magazine/archive/10.

At the present stage of reforming the housing sector in Russia, the main task of the state housing policy is - development of mechanisms for increasing the affordability of housing for various categories of the population.

To begin with, it is necessary to define the very concept of "accessibility", what exactly will be understood by it in the framework of this work.

Used in international and Russian practice, the concept of housing affordability means the possibility of purchasing housing by the consumer and is determined by the share of the total family income for the purchase of housing and annual payments at the bank's interest rate for a loan. The affordability of housing for the population can be defined as an integral category, which combines the main socio-economic, demographic characteristics of the region, parameters of the credit and financial system, etc.

The "affordable residential real estate market" is a set of economic mechanisms that contribute to an increase in the volume of reproduction of affordable residential real estate, its targeted distribution and consumption, as well as maintaining them and the housing and communal infrastructure in an appropriate technical condition based on the use of the main factors of production (land, labor, capital).

In modern Russian conditions, the question of the place and role of the affordable residential real estate market in the system of the national economy arises in a new way: the factor of the availability of housing for medium and low-income citizens is becoming very relevant on the agenda.

Affordable residential real estate market - this is a socio-economic system that will provide in Russia not only a solution to the most acute social problem - housing, but will also allow to intensify and increase the efficiency of the entire system of the national economy.

The housing policy pursued by the regional government is aimed at creating conditions for providing all categories of the population with affordable, high-quality and comfortable housing. Solving the housing problem is one of the main directions of the implementation of the Program for improving the quality of life of the region's population. Since the mid-1990s, active work has been underway in the Belgorod Region to implement targeted housing construction programs. Since 2003, the regional "Strategy for the development of housing construction in the Belgorod region until 2010" has been implemented, the priority of which is the construction of individual housing. The strategy fully meets the goals and objectives of the priority national project “Affordable and Comfortable Housing for the Citizens of Russia”.

During the period of implementation of the Strategy, the volume of housing construction in the region has increased significantly: the total commissioning of housing increased by 1.4 times, the commissioning of individual houses - 2 times. Currently, the regional target program "Development of housing construction in the territory of the Belgorod region in 2011-2015" is being implemented on the territory of the Belgorod region. and comfortable living conditions in it.

In terms of the volume of housing commissioned per 1000 people, the Belgorod Region takes 1st place among the regions of the Central Black Earth Region, among the regions of the Central Federal District - 2nd place after the Moscow Region.

Rice. 1. Commissioning of housing in the region in 2009-2012.

In practice, the main indicator of the state of the housing market from the point of view of the possibility of acquiring apartments by citizens is the coefficient of housing affordability.

In the FTP "Housing", two relevant indicators are proposed:

a) the housing affordability ratio (the ratio of the average market value of a standard apartment with a total area of ​​54 sq. m and the average annual total cash income of a family of three);

b) the proportion of families who have the opportunity to purchase housing that meets the standards for providing housing, using their own and borrowed funds.

It is planned that by 2010 the first coefficient will have a value of 3 (that is, the cost of a standard apartment will be equal to the average annual monetary income of a family for three years), and the second - 30% (that is, for 30% of families, the purchase of standard housing will be available with the help of own and borrowed funds).

Housing affordability ratio:

Kds = (C x S) / (D x N), (1)

where Kds is the housing affordability coefficient;

S is the area of ​​a conventional apartment, sq. M;

С - average cost per sq. m. of housing, rubles;

D is the average per capita family income, rubles / person. in year;

N is the number of people in the family.

Housing affordability ratio, taking into account the minimum consumption costs:

Kdr = (C x S) / ((D - P) x N), (2)

where Kdr is the coefficient of housing affordability, taking into account the minimum consumer spending;

Р - minimum per capita family expenses, rubles / person. in year.

It can be seen from the data in the table that over the course of 10 years the gap between incomes and expenditures of the population of the Belgorod region has been increasing. This fact is positive, since an increase in this gap leads to the emergence of free funds, which in most cases are invested in the purchase of their own housing.

The disadvantage of QJ calculated according to Formula 1 is that it does not take into account such an important indicator as per capita consumer spending, which varies considerably depending on the region.

The highest QoL was observed in 2004 - 13.7, the smallest - in 2009 and amounted to 9 years. In fig. 2 graphically shows the dynamics of this coefficient.

Indicators and results of calculating the housing affordability coefficient in the Belgorod region in 2002-2012.

Rice. 2. Dynamics of QJ taking into account consumer spending in the region for 2002-2012.

The graph shows that the QoL is decreasing, which only indicates that the affordability of housing in the region is increasing. But, nevertheless, today this figure is still high.

Monitoring and evaluating the results of the implementation of the national housing project in different regions, cities and settlements should be better ensured both methodologically and statistically. The methodology for assessing housing affordability indicators proposed in the Federal Target Program "Housing" and the additional indicators presented can be considered only as the first step towards the creation of a unified methodology that will allow a comprehensive assessment of housing affordability in Russia.

The indicators of housing affordability introduced in the Federal Target Program "Zhilishche" characterize only the affordability of buying housing, while the issues of accessibility of privatization, inheritance, construction, hiring (social and commercial), as well as payment of operating costs associated with the maintenance of housing are still open, which determines the relevance of identifying the factors that determine the specified components of housing affordability for the population, and indicators of their assessment.

In our opinion, the affordability of housing for the population should be understood somewhat broader than just the ability to purchase it. In our opinion, the problem of housing affordability should be considered in the aggregate of three main components of affordability: purchasing (receiving) housing for private ownership, renting housing and paying for current (periodic) costs associated with the maintenance, repair and operation of housing.

Thus, the need to expand the assessment of housing affordability beyond its purchase can be considered justified.

In addition, due to the local nature of housing markets, high territorial differentiation of household incomes and the level of development of mortgage lending, the analysis of factors and indicators of housing affordability must be carried out not only and not so much in the Russian Federation as a whole, but also in the regional and municipal context.

Based on the foregoing, it is obvious that the affordability of purchasing housing in Russia is gradually increasing. Unfortunately, it is obvious that at the moment housing is unaffordable for the majority of the population of Russia. Based on the foregoing, it is obvious that in order to increase the affordability of housing, it is not enough just to increase the effective demand of the population or supply in the real estate market; it is necessary to have a balanced impact on both demand and supply. State policy in this direction should play a key role.

Reviewers:

Kalugin VA, Doctor of Economics, Professor of the Department of Economics and Management at the Enterprise (in the Municipal Economy), Belgorod State National Research University, Belgorod;

Fliginskikh T.N., Doctor of Economics, Professor of the Department of Finance and Credit, Belgorod State National Research University, Belgorod.

The work was received on June 24, 2014.

Bibliographic reference

Influence of mortgage lending parameters on the housing affordability ratio (on the example of Moscow)

The development of the priority national project “Affordable and Comfortable Housing for the Citizens of Russia” has drawn the attention of the country's leadership, specialists and citizens to the concept of “affordable housing”. Social programs adopted within the framework of this project were aimed at supporting the least protected segments of the population - disabled people, pensioners, and military personnel. At the same time, it was believed that the bulk of the population was able to take care of themselves. In this case, the state assumed only the obligation to increase the volume of construction and develop more affordable credit systems. It was for the second “active” group of the population that the concept of “housing affordability” was introduced, and the housing affordability coefficient was taken as the main indicator of the project's success.

According to the basic calculation method, the affordability coefficient is defined as the ratio of the average price of a typical apartment to the total annual income of an average family and shows the number of years during which a family can accumulate from current income the amount necessary to purchase an apartment:

The affordability coefficient can take a value equal to zero (when the apartment is provided free of charge), one when the family's annual income is not less than the cost of the apartment, and it can grow indefinitely when the family's annual income approaches zero.

This indicator is widely used by the United Nations Human Settlements Development Program Habitat when comparing the situation in different countries. In the System of Target Indicators of the Federal Target Program "Housing" for 2002 - 2010 "it is assumed that the housing affordability coefficient is defined as the ratio of the average cost of a standard apartment of 54 sq. M. m and the average annual total cash income of a family of three. At the same time, it is indicated as a target indicator that the value of the housing affordability coefficient on average in Russia should decrease from 3.9 years in 2004 to 3.2 years in 2007 and to 3.0 years in 2010.

Calculations based on the initial data below showed that the actual values ​​of the affordability coefficient, averaged across the Russian Federation, amounted to 4.1 years in 2004, 4.0 years in 2005, and in 2006, due to the widespread rapid growth in housing prices, the Kd value increased to 4.6 years.

BASIC INDICATORS FOR CALCULATING THE RATIO OF AVAILABILITY OF HOUSING IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION in 2002-2006

1) according to the Federal State Statistics Service of the Russian Federation (initial data for the calculation)

Source: authors' calculations.

Calculations have shown that there are significant differences in the values ​​of the housing affordability coefficient for different regions. The values ​​for the federal districts differ almost twofold. For example, in October 2006, the minimum value of the housing affordability coefficient (2.4 years) was noted in the Central Federal District, and the maximum (4.7 years) in the Volga Federal District.

BASIC INDICATORS FOR CALCULATING THE RATIO OF AVAILABILITY OF HOUSING IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERAL DISTRICTS IN OCTOBER 2006

1) according to Rosstat of the Russian Federation
2) calculated according to AHML data

HOUSING AVAILABILITY RATIO IN DIFFERENT FEDERAL DISTRICTS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERAL DISTRICTS IN OCTOBER 2006

A more realistic assessment of housing affordability will be given by the model for calculations proposed by the Institute for Urban Economics Foundation, which takes into account the cost of annual operating expenses for all family needs in the form of the family's annual subsistence minimum.

The calculation results for this model are presented below.

BASIC INDICATORS FOR CALCULATING THE RATIO OF AVAILABILITY OF HOUSING IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION INIV KV. 2006 G.

1) according to the Federal State Statistics Service of the Russian Federation (initial data for the calculation).
2) calculated according to the Ministry of Economic Development and Trade

The dynamics of the affordability ratio according to the above formulas is presented in the following graph. The behavior of the housing affordability coefficient is seasonal (calendar) in nature and is associated with the well-known effect of the December increase and January decrease in per capita income. Excluding the first quarters, the value for option (1) (the standard UN Habitat indicator) in 2003 was approximately 3.8 years, in 2004 and 2005 its value increased slightly - to the level of 4.1 and 4.0 years, respectively. and in 2006 it increased to 4.6 years.

The values ​​of the housing affordability coefficient, taking into account the minimum annual family expenses (formula 2a), averaged 7.5 years in 2003-2005, and 7.7 years in 2006. Naturally, they exceed the values ​​obtained by formula (1), that is, they indicate a lower affordability of housing - on average, 1.8 times.

Source: authors' calculations.

However, the above formula does not reflect the possibility of a complete absence of savings from citizens, when the annual income is less than or equal to the minimum consumer spending. In, a modification of this formula was proposed in the form showing that if the condition "income is greater than expenses" is not met, Kd tends to infinity:

In pursuance of subparagraph "a" of paragraph 4 of the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On the assessment of the effectiveness of the activities of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation", the Government of the Russian Federation decides:

Approve attached:

Calculation of the indicator "The ratio of the average per capita money income of the population minus the amounts of mandatory payments and payments for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services";

Calculation of the indicator "Coefficient of housing affordability (the number of years required for a family of three to purchase a standard apartment with a total area of ​​54 square meters. Meters, taking into account the average annual total monetary income of the family)";

Calculation of the indicator "The number of days with a disruption in the supply of water, heat and electricity, on average per one inhabitant";

Calculation of the indicator "Ratio of average per capita cash expenditures of the population for payment of housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services";

Calculation of the indicator "The share of disposed municipal solid waste in the total volume of municipal solid waste";

Calculation of the indicator "The share of normatively treated wastewater in the total volume of wastewater";

Calculation of the indicator "The volume of investments in fixed assets (except for budgetary funds of the federal budget, investments in the extractive industries) per capita";

Calculation of the indicator "Density of the network of public highways (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators";

Calculation of the indicator "Assessment by the population of conditions for self-realization, including for self-realization of children";

Calculation of the indicator "Assessment of satisfaction of the population with services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services";

Calculation of the indicator "Percentage of residents of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation who faced manifestations of corruption";

Calculation of the indicator "Assessment by the population of the effectiveness of the activities of the state authorities of the Russian Federation";

Calculation of the indicator "Results of an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by organizations in the social sphere."

Methodology for calculating the indicator "The ratio of the average per capita money income of the population minus the amounts of mandatory payments and payments for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services"

1. This methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "The ratio of the average per capita monetary income of the population minus the amounts of mandatory payments and payments for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services" Federation, approved by the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On the assessment of the effectiveness of the activities of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation."

2. The indicator "The ratio of the average per capita money income of the population minus the amounts of mandatory payments and payments for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services" is calculated by the Federal State Statistics Service in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

"the amount of money income of the population" - income of persons engaged in entrepreneurial activities, wages of employees (including the pay of military personnel), social payments (pensions, allowances, scholarships and other payments), income from property in the form of interest on deposits, securities, dividends and other income.

The volume of monetary incomes of the population is calculated in accordance with the methodological provisions for the calculation of indicators of monetary income and expenditures of the population, approved by the Federal State Statistics Service;

"volume of compulsory payments" - taxes and fees, insurance premiums, interest paid by the population for loans.

The volume of compulsory payments is calculated in accordance with the methodological regulations for the calculation of indicators of monetary income and expenditures of the population, approved by the Federal State Statistics Service;

"payment for housing and communal services" is payment for the use of residential premises (rent), maintenance of residential premises, overhaul, cold water supply, water disposal, hot water supply, heating, electricity supply, gas supply (network or liquefied gas), supply of solid fuel in the presence of stove heating (coal, firewood), handling solid municipal waste.

The set includes 83 items of goods and services, including 30 types of food products, 41 types of non-food products and 12 types of services in accordance with Appendix No. 4 to the official statistical methodology for organizing statistical monitoring of consumer prices for goods and services and calculating consumer indices. prices approved by the Federal State Statistics Service. The data on the cost of the set are determined per month.

4. The source of information for calculating the indicator "Ratio of average per capita monetary income of the population minus the amounts of mandatory payments and payments for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services" are:

data of the federal statistical observation in the form No. 22-Housing and communal services (summary) "Information on the work of housing and communal organizations in the context of the reform", approved by the Federal State Statistics Service;

results of the All-Russian population census, data of the current population registration;

forms of federal state statistical observation and departmental reporting of government bodies, the Central Bank of the Russian Federation and other organizations on cash payments and settlements with the population, provided for in Appendix No. 2 to the methodological provisions for calculating indicators of cash income and expenses of the population, approved by the Federal State Statistics Service.

5. The ratio of the average per capita money income of the population minus the amounts of mandatory payments and payments for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services (CA) is determined by the formula:

,

Average per capita monetary income of the population minus the amounts of compulsory payments and payments for housing and communal services, rubles;

6. Average per capita monetary incomes of the population minus the amounts of compulsory payments and payments for housing and communal services (SDV) are determined by the formula:

,

ДДв - the total amount of monetary income of the population minus the amounts of mandatory payments and payments for housing and communal services, rubles;

7. The total amount of cash income minus the amounts of compulsory payments and payments for housing and communal services (DDV) is determined by the formula:

DD is the total amount of money income of the population, rubles;

OP - the amount of mandatory payments, rubles;

UZHKH - payment for housing and communal services, rubles.

9. The indicator "The ratio of the average per capita money income of the population minus the amounts of mandatory payments and payments for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, starting since 2020.

Methodology for calculating the indicator "Housing affordability ratio (the number of years required for a family of three to purchase a standard apartment with a total area of ​​54 square meters, taking into account the average annual total cash income of the family)"

1. This methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "Housing affordability coefficient (the number of years required for a family of three to purchase a standard apartment with a total area of ​​54 square meters. Meters, taking into account the average annual total monetary income of the family)" assessing the effectiveness of the activities of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On the assessment of the effectiveness of the activities of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation."

2. The indicator "Coefficient of housing affordability (the number of years required for a family of three to purchase a standard apartment with a total area of ​​54 square meters, taking into account the average annual total monetary income of the family)" is calculated by the Ministry of Construction breakdown of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the basic concept of "housing affordability coefficient" is used - a value that makes it possible to estimate the number of years required for a family of three to acquire a standard apartment with a total area of ​​54 sq. M. meter, taking into account the average annual total cash income of the population.

4. The coefficient of housing affordability (the number of years required for a family of three to purchase a standard apartment with a total area of ​​54 square meters, taking into account the average annual total monetary income of the family) is determined by the formula:

С - the average market value of 1 sq. meter of housing (information from the Federal State Statistics Service), rubles;

P - the total area of ​​the apartment (standard apartment with a total area of ​​54 square meters);

D - average per capita monetary income (information from the Federal State Statistics Service), rubles;

Family composition (people).

5. The indicator "Coefficient of housing affordability (the number of years required for a family of three to acquire a standard apartment with a total area of ​​54 square meters, taking into account the average annual total monetary income of the family)" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation within 15 August of the year following the reporting year, starting in 2020.

Methodology for calculating the indicator "The number of days with a disruption in the supply of water, heat and electricity, on average per one inhabitant"

1. The methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "The number of days with a disruption in the supply of water, heat and electricity, on average per one inhabitant", included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of activities, approved by the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On evaluating the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation ".

2. The indicator "The number of days with a disruption in the supply of water, heat and electricity, on average per one inhabitant" is calculated by the Ministry of Construction, Housing and Communal Services of the Russian Federation in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the basic concept is used "the number of days with a disruption in the supply of water, heat and electric energy on average per one inhabitant" - data on interruptions in the supply of cold and hot water, thermal and electric energy in relation to citizens living in apartment buildings in which the corresponding breaks occurred.

The source of information is the data contained in the state information system of housing and communal services, in accordance with clauses 2.12.8, 4.2.1.1, 4.2.2.1, 4.2.4.1, 4.2.6.1 of Section 10 of the composition, timing and frequency of posting information by information providers in state information system of housing and communal services, approved by the joint order of the Ministry of Communications and Mass Media of the Russian Federation No. 74 and the Ministry of Construction and Housing and Utilities of the Russian Federation No. 114 / pr dated February 29, 2016 "On approval of the composition, timing and frequency of information placement information providers in the state information system of housing and communal services ".

4. The number of days with a disruption in the supply of water, heat and electricity, on average, per one inhabitant per year (VTEEN) is determined by the formula:

HVSn - the number of days with a disruption in the supply of cold water per inhabitant;

GVSn - the number of days with a violation of the hot water supply per inhabitant;

Тн - the number of days with a violation of the supply of thermal energy per one inhabitant;

EEn - the number of days with a disruption in the supply of electrical energy per inhabitant.

5. The number of days with a violation of cold water supply per inhabitant (HVSn) is determined by the formula:

,

The number of hours of interruption in the supply of cold water per year at the i-th violation object, hours;

Number of cold water supply disruptions living at the i-th facility, people;

Nx is the total number of cold water supply disturbance objects per year, units.

6. The number of days with a violation of hot water supply per inhabitant (DHW) is determined by the formula:

,

The number of hours of hot water supply disruption per year at the i-th violation object, hours;

Number of hot water supply disruptions living at the i-th facility, people;

Ng is the total number of hot water supply disturbance objects per year, units;

7. The number of days with a violation of the supply of thermal energy per inhabitant (Тн) is determined by the formula:

,

The number of hours of violation of the supply of thermal energy per year at the i-th object of violation, hours;

The number of people living at the i-th object of thermal energy disturbance;

Nт - the total number of objects of thermal energy disturbance per year, units.

8. The number of days with a violation of the supply of electrical energy per inhabitant (EEI) is determined by the formula:

,

The number of hours of disruption in the supply of electrical energy per year at the i-th object of the violation, hours;

The number of people living at the i-th object of power supply disruption, people;

Ne - the total number of objects of disruption in the supply of electrical energy per year, units.

9. The indicator "The number of days with a disruption in the supply of water, heat and electricity, on average per one inhabitant" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, annually, starting from 2020.

Methodology for calculating the indicator "The ratio of average per capita cash expenditures of the population to pay for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services"

1. This methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "Ratio of average per capita cash expenditures of the population for payment of housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services" included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by the Presidential Decree Of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On the assessment of the effectiveness of the activities of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation."

2. The indicator "Ratio of average per capita cash expenditures of the population on payment for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services" is calculated by the Federal State Statistics Service in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the following basic concepts are used:

"expenses for payment of housing and communal services" - payment by the population for housing and communal services living in apartment buildings and residential buildings (individually defined buildings).

Payment for housing and communal services is payment for the use of a dwelling (rent), maintenance of a dwelling, overhaul, cold water supply, sewerage, hot water supply, heating, electricity supply, gas supply (network or liquefied gas), supply of solid fuel when the presence of stove heating (coal, firewood), the handling of municipal solid waste.

The amount of accrued housing and communal payments is reflected taking into account the discounts provided for certain categories of citizens of social support measures and subsidies for payment of housing and communal services;

"average annual resident population" - the arithmetic average of the resident population at the beginning and end of the corresponding year.

The calculation of the population is carried out in accordance with the methodological guidelines for assessing the total population, approved by the Federal State Statistics Service, and refers only to the final data obtained for the year;

"the cost of a fixed set of consumer goods and services" - a single conditionally consumed quantity of goods and services and actual average consumer prices in the Russian Federation, federal districts and constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

The set includes 83 items of goods and services, including 30 types of food products, 41 types of non-food products and 12 types of services in accordance with Appendix No. 4 to the official statistical methodology for organizing statistical monitoring of consumer prices for goods and services and calculating consumer indices. prices of services approved by the Federal State Statistics Service. The data on the cost of the set are determined per month.

4. The source of information on the costs of housing and communal services is the data of the federal statistical observation in the form No. 22-Housing and communal services (consolidated) "Information on the work of housing and communal services in the context of the reform", approved by the Federal State Statistics Service.

5. The source of information for calculating the cost of a fixed set of consumer goods and services is the list of goods and services included in the specified set, which is approved by the Federal State Statistics Service.

6. The ratio of average per capita cash expenditures of the population to pay for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services is determined by the formula:

Average per capita cash expenditures of the population to pay for housing and communal services, rubles;

FN is the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services, rubles.

7. Average per capita cash expenditures of the population to pay for housing and communal services are determined by the formula:

The total amount of cash expenses for payment of housing and communal services, rubles;

Average annual resident population for the reporting year, people.

8. The average annual resident population is determined by the formula:

Resident population at the beginning of the year t, people;

Resident population at the end of the year t (at the beginning of the year t + 1), people.

9. The indicator "Ratio of average per capita cash expenditures of the population to pay for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, starting in 2020.

Methodology for calculating the indicator "The share of disposed municipal solid waste in the total volume of municipal solid waste"

1. This methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "The share of recycled municipal solid waste in the total volume of municipal solid waste" included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On the assessment of the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation."

2. The indicator "The share of recycled municipal solid waste in the total volume of municipal solid waste" is calculated by the Federal Service for Supervision of Natural Resources in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the following basic concepts are used:

"disposed municipal solid waste" - the volume of municipal solid waste disposed of during the reporting period;

"total volume of municipal solid waste" - the amount of municipal solid waste generated in the reporting period.

4. The source of information for calculating the indicator "The share of recycled municipal solid waste in the total volume of municipal solid waste" is the generalized data of the federal statistical observation in the form No. 2-tp (waste) "Information on the generation, processing, utilization, disposal, transportation and disposal of waste production and consumption ", approved by the Federal State Statistics Service.

5. The share of disposed municipal solid waste in the total volume of municipal solid waste (F) is determined by the formula:

Disposed municipal solid waste, tons;

The amount of solid municipal waste generated during the reporting period, tons.

6. The indicator "The share of recycled municipal solid waste in the total volume of municipal solid waste" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, starting from 2020.

Methodology for calculating the indicator "The share of normatively treated wastewater in the total volume of wastewater"

1. This methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "The share of normatively treated wastewater in the total volume of wastewater" included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 " On the assessment of the effectiveness of the activities of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation ".

2. The indicator "The share of normatively treated wastewater in the total volume of wastewater" is calculated by the Federal Agency for Water Resources in relation to the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the following basic concepts are used:

"normatively treated waste water" - waste water, the content of pollutants in which after treatment at the treatment plant does not exceed the permissible values ​​established by the permitting document;

"total wastewater volume" is the volume of wastewater to be treated.

4. The source of information for calculating the indicator "The share of normatively treated wastewater in the total volume of wastewater" is the generalized data of the federal statistical observation according to the form No. 2-tp (vodkhoz) "Information on water use", approved by the Federal State Statistics Service.

5. The share of normatively treated wastewater in the total volume of wastewater is determined by the formula:

,

The volume of wastewater treated according to regulations, mln. m;

Total wastewater volume, million cubic meters m.

6. The indicator "The share of normatively treated wastewater in the total volume of wastewater" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, starting from 2020.

Methodology for calculating the indicator "Volume of investments in fixed assets (except for budgetary funds of the federal budget, investments in extractive industries) per capita"

1. This methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "The volume of investments in fixed assets (except for budgetary funds of the federal budget, investments in the extractive industries) per capita" included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On the assessment of the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation."

2. The indicator "The volume of investments in fixed assets (except for budgetary funds of the federal budget, investments in the extractive industries) per capita" is calculated by the Federal State Statistics Service in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the following basic concepts are used:

"investment in fixed assets" - a set of costs aimed at the construction, reconstruction (including expansion and modernization) of facilities that lead to an increase in the initial cost of facilities, the acquisition of machinery, equipment, vehicles, production and household inventory, the accounting of which is carried out in accordance with the procedure established for accounting for investments in non-current assets, investments in intellectual property, cultivated biological resources (in accordance with the All-Russian Classifier of Fixed Assets OK 013-2014 (SNA 2008).

The composition of investments in fixed assets is determined in accordance with the official statistical methodology for determining investments in fixed assets at the federal level, approved by the Federal State Statistics Service.

In order to avoid double counting, investments in fixed assets by constituent entities of the Russian Federation are assessed only in terms of the creation and acquisition of new fixed assets.

The volume of investments in fixed assets is formed for the full range of economic entities on the basis of annual reports of large and medium-sized organizations, small and micro-enterprises and economic calculations of investment resources in the Russian Federation as a whole.

The volume of investments in fixed assets at the expense of budgetary funds of the federal budget is determined on the basis of information on the sources of financing investments in fixed assets provided by respondents in the forms of federal statistical observation in accordance with this methodology.

The volume of investments in fixed assets in the extractive industries is determined by:

for large and medium-sized organizations - based on data on investments aimed at the development of activities included in the section "Mining" of the All-Russian Classifier of Economic Activities OK 029-2014 (NACE Rev. 2);

for small and micro-enterprises - on the basis of data on investments of enterprises registered by types of economic activities included in the section "Mining" of the All-Russian Classifier of Types of Economic Activities OK 029-2014 (NACE Rev. 2);

"average annual resident population" - the arithmetic average of the resident population at the beginning and end of the corresponding year.

The calculation of the population is carried out in accordance with the methodological guidelines for assessing the total population, approved by the Federal State Statistics Service, and refers only to the final data obtained for the year.

4. The source of information for calculating the indicator "The volume of investments in fixed assets (except for the budgetary funds of the federal budget, investments in the extractive industries) per capita" is the data of the federal statistical observation according to forms No. P-2 (invest) "Information on investment activities", No. PM "Information on the main performance indicators of a small enterprise" and No. MP (micro) "Information on the main performance indicators of a micro-enterprise", approved by the Federal State Statistics Service, and economic calculations. The population size is determined on the basis of the results of the All-Russian Population Census and data of the current population registration.

5. The volume of investments in fixed assets (except for budgetary funds of the federal budget, investments in the extractive industries) per capita (V) is determined by the formula:

The volume of investments in fixed assets (except for budgetary funds of the federal budget, investments in the extractive industries) for the reporting year (in current prices), thousand rubles;

Average annual resident population for the reporting year, people.

6. The volume of investments in fixed assets (except for budgetary funds of the federal budget, investments in the extractive industries) for the reporting year (in current prices) is determined by the formula:

The volume of investments in fixed assets for the full range of economic entities, taking into account the assessment of the volume of investments not observed by direct statistical methods for the reporting year (in current prices);

The volume of investments in fixed assets at the expense of the federal budget for the reporting year (at current prices);

The volume of investments in fixed assets in the extractive industries for the reporting year (at current prices).

7. The average annual resident population is determined by the formula:

Resident population at the beginning of the year t, people;

Resident population at the end of the year t (at the beginning of the year t + 1), people.

8. The indicator "The volume of investments in fixed assets (except for budgetary funds of the federal budget, investments in the extractive industries) per capita" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, starting from 2020.

Methodology for calculating the indicator "Density of the network of public highways (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators"

1. This methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "Density of the network of public highways (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators" included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by the Presidential Decree Of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On the assessment of the effectiveness of the activities of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation."

2. The indicator "Density of the network of public highways (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators" is calculated by the Ministry of Transport of the Russian Federation in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the following basic concepts are used:

"motor road" - an object of transport infrastructure intended for the movement of vehicles and includes land plots within the boundaries of the right-of-way of a motor road and structural elements located on them or under them (roadbed, road surface and similar elements) and road structures that are its technological part, - protective road structures, artificial road structures, production facilities, elements of the arrangement of highways;

"public highways" - highways intended for the movement of vehicles of an unlimited number of persons.

The length of the road is calculated from the initial settlement to the final settlement or to the state border of the Russian Federation. The length of a motor road within the boundaries of a settlement is calculated from the starting point to the end point of the motor road along its central axis.

As a conditional starting point and conditional end point of reference of the length of a motor road, as a rule, are taken:

the sign of the zero kilometer of highways, installed in the capital of the Russian Federation, Moscow, for highways that start in the capital of the Russian Federation, Moscow;

separate subdivisions of postal organizations, a building of a state authority or a local self-government body or other building or structure located in the center of a settlement - for a motor road connecting settlements;

crossing of motor roads - for a motor road connecting or adjacent to other motor roads;

boundaries of geographical, historical and other objects - for public highways connecting these objects.

4. The source of information for calculating the indicator "Density of the network of public highways (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators" are:

Federal statistical observation form No. 1-DG "Information on public roads and structures on them of federal, regional or intermunicipal significance", approved by the Federal State Statistics Service (hereinafter - Form No. 1-DG);

Federal statistical observation form No. 3-DG (MO) "Information on public roads of local importance and artificial structures on them owned by municipalities", approved by the Federal State Statistics Service (hereinafter - Form No. 3-DG (MO);

federal statistical observation form No. 22-2 "Information on the availability and distribution of lands by category and land", approved by the Federal State Statistics Service (hereinafter - form No. 22-2).

5. Information for calculating the indicator "Density of the network of public highways (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators" is provided by the Federal Road Agency (according to the form No. 1-DG), the Federal State Statistics Service (according to the form No. 3-DG (MO), the Federal Service for State Registration, Cadastre and Cartography (according to form No. 22-2) to the Ministry of Transport of the Russian Federation for the period necessary to calculate the efficiency of activities, annually, by June 15 of the year following the reporting year.

6. The density of the network of public highways (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators is determined by the formula:

The length of public highways (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, km;

The area of ​​the territory of the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation thousand sq. km.

7. The length of public highways (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators in the i-th subject of the Russian Federation is determined by the formula:

The length of public roads of regional or intermunicipal importance in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, km;

Length of motor roads of general use of local importance in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, km;

The length of public roads of regional or intermunicipal importance that do not meet regulatory requirements in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, km;

Length of local public highways that do not meet regulatory requirements in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, km.

8. The indicator "Density of the network of public roads (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, starting from 2020.

Methodology for calculating the indicator "Assessment by the population of conditions for self-realization, including for the self-realization of children"

1. This methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "Assessment by the population of conditions for self-realization, including for the self-realization of children", included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of the activities of executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On the assessment of the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation".

2. The indicator "Assessment by the population of conditions for self-realization, including for the self-realization of children" is calculated by the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation on average across the Russian Federation and in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the following basic concepts are used:

"self-realization" - the process of the fullest identification and realization by a person of his capabilities, achievement of the intended goals in solving significant problems, which allow him to fully realize the creative potential of the individual;

"conditions for self-realization" - a set of external factors necessary for the realization of individual potential.

4. The initial data for the formation of the indicator "Assessment by the population of conditions for self-realization, including for the self-realization of children" are the results of sociological surveys conducted by the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation on a representative sample of 300 to 800 respondents (depending on the size of the population region) with a frequency of 2 - 3 times a year. The results of sociological surveys are understood as the distribution of the frequency of responses of respondents (as a percentage of the number of respondents) to the questions given in the methodology.

For each of the questions, a choice of one answer is allowed ("favorable", "rather favorable", "rather unfavorable", "unfavorable", "difficult to answer").

5. The indicator "Assessment by the population of conditions for self-realization, including for self-realization of children" is formed from:

the respondents' assessment of the conditions for self-realization in the subject of residence;

the respondents' assessments of the conditions for self-realization of children in the subject of residence.

6. The current value of the indicator "Assessment by the population of conditions for self-realization, including for the self-realization of children" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation is determined by the formula:

,

The current value of the indicator "Respondents' assessment of conditions for self-realization in the subject of residence" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation based on the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The current value of the indicator "Respondents' assessment of the conditions for self-realization of children in the subject of residence" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

Percentage of respondents who chose the answer option "favorable" to the question about the population's assessment of conditions for self-realization, among citizens interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "rather favorable" to the question about the population's assessment of conditions for self-realization among citizens surveyed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

Percentage of respondents who chose the answer option "favorable" to the question about the population's assessment of conditions for the comprehensive development of children among citizens surveyed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

Percentage of respondents who chose the answer option “rather favorable” to the question about the population's assessment of conditions for the comprehensive development of children among citizens surveyed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

9. The value of the indicator "Assessment by the population of conditions for self-realization, including for the self-realization of children" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation for the reporting year is the arithmetic average of the current values ​​of the indicator obtained in the g-th year, and is determined by the formula:

,

The current value of the indicator characterizing the assessment by the population of the i-th subject of the Russian Federation of the conditions for self-realization according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

10. The value of the indicator "Assessment by the population of conditions for self-realization, including for the self-realization of children" in the Russian Federation is determined by averaging the values ​​of the indicator for the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, taking into account the size of their population, according to the formula:

,

The value of the indicator characterizing the assessment by the population of the i-th subject of the Russian Federation of the conditions for self-realization, according to the results of sociological surveys conducted in the g-th year, percent;

11. The indicator "Assessment by the population of conditions for self-realization, including for the self-realization of children" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, annually, starting from 2020.

APPLICATION
to the calculation of the indicator
"Assessment of conditions by the population
for self-realization, including
for self-realization of children "

1. How do you generally assess the conditions for self-realization (the ability to achieve the desired social status through your abilities and efforts) in the subject of your residence?

2. How do you generally assess the conditions for the comprehensive development of children in accordance with their capabilities and needs (the presence of institutions of additional education, sports clubs, amateur art circles, etc.) in the subject of your residence?

Methodology for calculating the indicator "Assessment of satisfaction of the population with services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services"

1. This methodology defines the procedure for calculating the indicator "Assessment of population satisfaction with services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services" included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 . № 548 "On the assessment of the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation."

2. The indicator "Assessment of satisfaction of the population with services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services" is calculated by the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation on average in the Russian Federation and in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the following basic concepts are used:

"satisfaction of the population" - a positive attitude of a group of people to the subject of assessment, which arises as a result of comparing the real properties and qualities of the subject of assessment with expectations;

"education" is a single purposeful process of upbringing and education, which is a socially significant benefit and is carried out in the interests of a person, family, society and the state, as well as a set of acquired knowledge, skills, skills, values, experience and competence for the purpose of intellectual, spiritual moral, creative, physical and (or) professional development of a person, satisfaction of his educational needs and interests;

"health care" is a system of measures of a political, economic, legal, social, scientific, medical, including sanitary and anti-epidemic (preventive) ones, carried out by the state authorities of the Russian Federation, state authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, local self-government bodies, organizations, including those of private ownership, their officials and other persons, citizens in order to prevent diseases, preserve and strengthen the physical and mental health of each person, maintain his long active life, provide him with medical assistance in case of deteriorating health;

"culture" - the sphere of industrial, social and spiritual achievements of people, including a system of organizations designed to meet the aesthetic, entertainment, information needs of citizens;

"social services for citizens" - activities to provide social services to citizens;

"social service" - an action or actions in the field of social services for the provision of constant, periodic, one-time assistance, including urgent assistance, to a citizen in order to improve his living conditions and (or) expand his ability to independently provide for his basic life needs.

4. The initial data for the formation of the indicator "Assessment of population satisfaction with services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services" are the results of sociological surveys conducted by the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation on a representative sample of 300 to 800 respondents (depending on population of the region) with a frequency of 2 - 3 times a year. The result of sociological surveys is understood as the distribution of respondents' answers (as a percentage of the number of respondents) to the questions given in the methodology.

For each of the questions, the choice of one answer is allowed ("completely satisfied", "rather satisfied", "rather dissatisfied", "not satisfied", "difficult to answer").

5. The indicator "Assessment of satisfaction of the population with services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services" is formed from:

satisfaction of the population with educational services;

satisfaction of the population with health services;

satisfaction of the population with cultural services;

satisfaction of the population with services in the field of social services.

6. The current value of the indicator "Assessment of satisfaction of the population with services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation is determined by the formula:

The current value of the indicator "Satisfaction of the population with educational services" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The current value of the indicator "Satisfaction of the population with health services" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation based on the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The current value of the indicator "Satisfaction of the population with services in the field of culture" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The current value of the indicator "Satisfaction of the population with services in the field of social services" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

7. The value of the indicator is determined by the formula:

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "completely satisfied" to the question about satisfaction with the quality of services in the field of education, among respondents interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year , percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "rather satisfied" to the question about satisfaction with the quality of services in the field of education, among the respondents interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year , percent.

8. The value of the indicator is determined by the formula:

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "completely satisfied" to the question about satisfaction with the quality of services in the healthcare sector, among respondents interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year , percent;

The proportion of respondents who chose the answer option "rather satisfied" to the question about satisfaction with the quality of healthcare services, among respondents interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year , percent.

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "completely satisfied" to the question about satisfaction with the quality of services in the field of culture, among respondents interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year , percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "rather satisfied" to the question about satisfaction with the quality of services in the field of culture, among the respondents interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year , percent.

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "fully satisfied" to the question about satisfaction with the quality of services in the field of social services, among respondents interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "rather satisfied" to the question about satisfaction with the quality of services in the field of social services, among the respondents interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

11. The value of the indicator "Assessment of satisfaction of the population with services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation for the reporting year is the arithmetic average of the current values ​​of the indicator obtained in the g-th year, and is determined by the formula:

,

The current value of the indicator characterizing the assessment by the population of the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation of the quality of the provision of services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services based on the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

N (g) - the number of opinion polls in the g-th year, units.

12. The value of the indicator "Assessment of satisfaction of the population with services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services" in the Russian Federation is determined by averaging the values ​​of the indicator for the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, taking into account their population according to the formula:

,

R is the total number of constituent entities of the Russian Federation, units;

The value of the indicator characterizing the satisfaction of the population of the i-th subject of the Russian Federation with the quality of the provision of services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services according to the results of sociological surveys conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of the adult population of the i-th subject of the Russian Federation in the adult population of the Russian Federation, where.

13. The indicator "Assessment of satisfaction of the population with services in the spheres of education, health care, culture, social services" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, annually, starting from 2020.

Application
to the calculation of the indicator
"Satisfaction assessment
population services in the spheres
education, health care,
culture, social service "

Questions to respondents to conduct surveys

1. Are you satisfied with the educational services provided to you (your relatives, friends, acquaintances) in the subject of your residence?

2. Are you satisfied with the healthcare services provided to you (your relatives, friends, acquaintances) in the subject of your residence?

3. Are you satisfied with the cultural services that are provided to you (your relatives, friends, acquaintances) in the subject of your residence?

4. Are you satisfied with the social services that are provided to you (your relatives, friends, acquaintances) in the subject of your residence?

Methodology for calculating the indicator "Share of residents of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation who faced manifestations of corruption"

1. This methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "The share of residents of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation who faced manifestations of corruption" included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of the executive authorities of constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by Decree of the President of the Russian Federation No. 548 dated November 14, 2017 " On the assessment of the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation ".

2. The indicator "The share of residents of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation who have encountered manifestations of corruption" is calculated by the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation on average throughout the Russian Federation and in the context of constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the basic concept of "corruption" is used - abuse of office, giving a bribe, accepting a bribe, abuse of authority, commercial bribery or other illegal use by an individual of his official position contrary to the legitimate interests of society and the state in order to obtain benefits in the form of money , valuables, other property or services of a property nature, other property rights for oneself or for third parties, or illegal provision of such benefits to the specified person by other individuals, as well as the commission of these acts on behalf of or in the interests of a legal entity.

4. The initial data for the formation of the indicator "Percentage of residents of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation who have encountered manifestations of corruption" are the results of opinion polls conducted by the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation in constituent entities of the Russian Federation on a representative sample of 300 to 800 respondents (depending on the size of the region's population) with a frequency of 1 - 2 times a year. The results of sociological surveys are understood as the distribution of the frequency of responses of respondents (as a percentage of the number of respondents) to the question given in this methodology.

For the specified question, it is allowed to choose one answer option ("yes, once", "yes, several times", "no, did not come across (did not come across)", "I find it difficult to answer").

5. The current value of the indicator "The share of residents of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation who faced manifestations of corruption" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation is the sum of the answers "yes, once" and "yes, several times" (as a percentage of the number of respondents) and is determined according to the formula:

The share of respondents who chose the answer "yes, once" to the question of whether they had to resort to informal remuneration among citizens surveyed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "yes, several times" to the question of whether they had to resort to informal remuneration among citizens surveyed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year , percent.

6. The value of the indicator "Share of residents of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation who faced manifestations of corruption" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation for the reporting year is the arithmetic average of the current values ​​of the indicator obtained in the g-th year, and is determined by the formula:

,

The current value of the indicator that determines the proportion of respondents who have encountered manifestations of corruption in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

N (g) - the number of opinion polls in the g-th year, units.

7. The value of the indicator "The share of residents of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation who faced manifestations of corruption" in the Russian Federation is determined by averaging the values ​​of the indicator for constituent entities of the Russian Federation, taking into account their population according to the formula:

,

R is the total number of constituent entities of the Russian Federation, units;

The value of the indicator that determines the proportion of respondents who have encountered manifestations of corruption in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of sociological surveys conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of the adult population of the i-th subject of the Russian Federation in the adult population of the Russian Federation, where.

8. The indicator "Percentage of residents of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation who have encountered manifestations of corruption" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, annually, starting from 2020.

Application
to the calculation of the indicator
"The share of residents of the subject
The Russian Federation faced
with manifestations of corruption "

Question to respondents for conducting surveys

Over the past 12 months, have you encountered manifestations of corruption (giving a bribe, accepting a bribe, abuse of power, etc.), if so, how often?

Methodology for calculating the indicator "Assessment by the population of the effectiveness of the activities of state authorities of the Russian Federation"

1. This methodology determines the procedure for calculating the indicator "Evaluation of the effectiveness of the activities of public authorities of the Russian Federation" by the population, included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On evaluating the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation ".

2. The indicator "Assessment by the population of the effectiveness of the activities of state authorities of the Russian Federation" is calculated by the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation on average throughout the Russian Federation and in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the basic concept of "efficiency" is used - the ability to perform work and achieve the necessary or desired result with the least expenditure of time and effort.

4. The initial data for the formation of the indicator "Population's assessment of the effectiveness of the activities of state authorities of the Russian Federation" are the results of sociological surveys conducted by the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation on a representative sample of 300 to 800 respondents (depending on the population of the region) with periodicity 2 - 3 times a year. The results of sociological surveys are understood as the distribution of the frequency of responses of respondents (as a percentage of the number of respondents) to the questions given in this methodology.

For the question specified in the appendix to this methodology, it is allowed to choose one answer ("very positive, active supporter", "positive", "with some positive interest", "indifferent", "with some caution", "negative", " sharply negative, active opponent "," I know nothing about his activities "," I find it difficult to answer ").

For each of the questions specified in the appendix to this methodology, it is allowed to choose one answer option ("definitely positive", "rather positive", "rather negative", "definitely negative", "I do not know anything about his (her or their) activities "," I find it difficult to answer ").

5. The indicator "Assessment by the population of the effectiveness of the activities of state authorities of the Russian Federation" is formed from:

the attitude of the population to the activities of the President of the Russian Federation;

the attitude of the population to the activities of the Government of the Russian Federation;

the attitude of the population to the activities of senior officials (heads of the highest executive bodies of state power) of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation;

the attitude of the population to the activities of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation;

the attitude of the population to the activities of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation;

the attitude of the population to the activities of legislative (representative) bodies of state power (Regional Duma, State Council, People's Khural, etc.) of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation;

the attitude of the population to the activities of the judicial authorities of the Russian Federation.

6. The current value of the indicator "Assessment by the population of the effectiveness of the activities of public authorities of the Russian Federation" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation is determined by the formula:

The current value of the indicator "Attitude of the population to the activities of the President of the Russian Federation" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The current value of the indicator "Attitude of the population to the activities of the Government of the Russian Federation" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation based on the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The current value of the indicator "Attitude of the population to the activities of senior officials (heads of the highest executive bodies of state power) of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation based on the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The current value of the indicator "Attitude of the population to the activities of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation based on the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The current value of the indicator "Attitude of the population to the activities of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The current value of the indicator "Attitude of the population to the activities of legislative (representative) bodies of state power (Regional Duma, State Council, People's Khural, etc.) of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation based on the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in g -m year, percent;

The current value of the indicator "Attitude of the population to the activities of the judicial authorities of the Russian Federation" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

7. The value of the indicator is determined by the formula:

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "very positive, active supporter" to the question about the attitude to the activities of the President of the Russian Federation, among citizens interviewed in the i-th subject of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

Percentage of respondents who chose the answer "yes" to the question about their attitude to the activities of the President of the Russian Federation, from among the citizens interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "with some positive interest" to the question about their attitude to the activities of the President of the Russian Federation, among citizens interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent ...

8. The value of the indicator is determined by the formula:

Percentage of respondents who chose the answer option "definitely positive" to the question about their attitude to the activities of the Government of the Russian Federation, among citizens surveyed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The percentage of respondents who chose the answer "rather positive" to the question about their attitude to the activities of the Government of the Russian Federation among citizens surveyed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

9. The value of the indicator is determined by the formula:

The percentage of respondents who chose the answer option "definitely positive" to the question about the attitude to the activities of senior officials of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, among the citizens interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "rather positively" to the question about the attitude towards the activities of senior officials of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, among citizens interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

10. The value of the indicator is determined by the formula:

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "definitely positive" to the question about the attitude to the activities of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, among citizens interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer "rather positively" to the question about the attitude to the activities of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, among citizens interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

11. The value of the indicator is determined by the formula:

The percentage of respondents who chose the answer option "definitely positive" to the question about their attitude to the activities of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, among citizens interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "rather positively" to the question about their attitude to the activities of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, among citizens interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

12. The value of the indicator is determined by the formula:

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "definitely positive" to the question about the attitude to the activities of the legislative (representative) body of state power (Regional Duma, State Council, People's Khural, etc.) of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, among citizens surveyed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "rather positively" to the question about the attitude to the activities of the legislative (representative) body of state power (Regional Duma, State Council, People's Khural, etc.) of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in g-th year, percent.

13. The value of the indicator is determined by the formula:

The share of respondents who chose the answer option "definitely positive" to the question about the attitude to the activities of the judicial authorities of the Russian Federation, among citizens interviewed in the i-th subject of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

The share of respondents who chose the answer "rather positive" to the question about the attitude to the activities of the judicial authorities of the Russian Federation, among citizens interviewed in the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent.

14. The value of the indicator "Assessment by the population of the effectiveness of the activities of public authorities of the Russian Federation" for the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation for the reporting year is the arithmetic average of the current values ​​of the indicator obtained in the g-th year, and is determined by the formula:

,

The current value of the indicator characterizing the assessment by the population of the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation of the effectiveness of the activities of public authorities of the Russian Federation, according to the results of the k-th sociological survey conducted in the g-th year, percent;

N (g) - the number of opinion polls in the g-th year, units.

15. The value of the indicator "Assessment by the population of the effectiveness of the activities of state authorities of the Russian Federation" in the Russian Federation is determined by averaging the values ​​of the indicator for the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, taking into account the size of their population, according to the formula:

,

The value of the indicator characterizing the assessment by the population of the i-th constituent entity of the Russian Federation of the effectiveness of the activities of the state authorities of the Russian Federation, according to the results of sociological surveys conducted in the g-th year, percent;

R is the total number of constituent entities of the Russian Federation, units;

The share of the adult population of the i-th subject of the Russian Federation in the adult population of the Russian Federation, where.

16. The indicator "Evaluation by the population of the effectiveness of the government bodies of the Russian Federation" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, annually, starting from 2020.

Application
to the indicator
"Assessment by the population
performance efficiency
public authorities
Russian Federation"

Questions to respondents to conduct surveys

1. How do you feel about the activities of the President of the Russian Federation?

2. What is your general attitude to the activities of the Government of the Russian Federation?

3. How do you feel about the activities of a senior official (head of the highest executive body - the governor, head of administration, etc.) of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation where you live?

4. How do you feel about the activities of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation?

5. How do you feel about the activities of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation?

6. How do you feel about the activities of the legislative (representative) body of state power (Regional Duma, State Council, People's Khural, etc.) of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation where you live?

7. What is your general attitude to the activities of the judicial authorities of the Russian Federation?

Methodology for calculating the indicator "Results of an independent assessment of the quality of service delivery by social organizations"

1. This methodology defines the procedure for calculating the indicator "Results of an independent assessment of the quality of service delivery by social organizations" included in the list of indicators for assessing the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, approved by the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of November 14, 2017 No. 548 "On assessment of the effectiveness of the executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. "

2. The indicator "Results of an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by organizations in the social sphere" is calculated by the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection of the Russian Federation in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

3. For the purposes of this methodology, the following basic concepts are used:

"the result of an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by organizations in the social sphere" - a consolidated quantitative assessment of the quality of the conditions for the provision of services by organizations in the field of culture, health, education and social services located on the territory of the subject of the Russian Federation, in respect of which an independent quality assessment was carried out, with the exception of organizations the founder of which is the Russian Federation;

"sectoral result of an independent assessment of the quality of the conditions for the provision of services by organizations of the relevant sector of the social sphere" - a quantitative assessment of the quality of the conditions for the provision of services by organizations of the corresponding sector of the social sphere of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, in respect of which an independent assessment of the quality was carried out, expressed in points.

4. An independent assessment of the quality of the conditions for the provision of services by social organizations is carried out in accordance with the indicators approved by the authorized federal executive bodies responsible for the development of state policy and legal regulation in the established area of ​​activity.

5. The source of information for calculating the indicator "Results of an independent assessment of the quality of service delivery by social organizations" is information on the sectoral results of an independent assessment of the quality of service delivery by social organizations, formed based on the results of an independent assessment of the quality of service delivery by social organizations, posted on the official website for posting information about state and municipal institutions in the information and telecommunications network "Internet" in the manner determined in accordance with the Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation dated November 14, 2014 No. 1203 "On the authorized federal executive body determining the composition of information on the results of an independent quality assessment the conditions for the implementation of educational activities by organizations carrying out educational activities, the conditions for the provision of services by cultural organizations, social services, medical organizations, federal institutions of medical and social expertise, including uniform requirements for such information, and the procedure for posting it on the official website for posting information about state and municipal institutions in the information and telecommunications network "Internet".

6. Information for calculating the indicator "Results of an independent assessment of the quality of services provided by organizations in the social sphere" is submitted by the Federal Treasury to the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection of the Russian Federation (by June 15 of the year following the reporting year) in the form of sectoral results of an independent assessment of the quality of services provided by organizations in the field of culture, health protection, education and social services in the context of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation for the reporting period, calculated in accordance with this methodology.

7. The indicator "Results of an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by organizations in the social sphere" (P) represents the level of achievement of the maximum value of the results of an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by organizations in the social sphere in the constituent entity of the Russian Federation and is calculated by the formula:

Sectoral result of an independent assessment of the quality of the conditions for the provision of services by organizations of the relevant sector of the social sphere in the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, in respect of which an independent assessment of the quality was carried out in the reporting year, points;

Sectoral result of an independent assessment of the quality of the conditions for the provision of services by organizations in the field of culture, in respect of which an independent assessment of the quality was carried out in the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, for the reporting year, points;

Sectoral result of an independent assessment of the quality of the conditions for the provision of services by organizations in the field of health care, in respect of which an independent assessment of the quality in the constituent entity of the Russian Federation was carried out, for the reporting year, points;

Sectoral result of an independent assessment of the quality of the conditions for the provision of services by organizations in the field of education, in relation to which an independent assessment of the quality in the constituent entity of the Russian Federation was carried out, points for the reporting year;

Sectoral result of an independent assessment of the quality of the conditions for the provision of services by organizations in the field of social services, in respect of which an independent assessment of the quality was carried out in the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, for the reporting year, points;

Q is the number of social sectors in which in the constituent entity of the Russian Federation in the reporting year an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by social sector organizations was carried out, units;

M is the maximum possible value of the results of an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by organizations in the social sphere, which a constituent entity of the Russian Federation can receive based on the results of an independent assessment of the quality in the reporting year (100 points), points.

8. The sectoral result of an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by organizations in the social sphere in a constituent entity of the Russian Federation is calculated as the arithmetic mean of the results of an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by organizations in the social sphere for organizations of the corresponding sector of the social sphere in the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, in respect of which such an assessment was carried out, according to the formula :

The final independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by the n-th organization of the relevant branch of the social sphere, in relation to which in the reporting year, an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by organizations of the social sphere was carried out, calculated in accordance with a unified procedure for calculating indicators characterizing the general criteria for assessing the quality of the conditions for the provision of services by organizations in in the sphere of culture, health protection, education, social services and federal institutions of medical and social expertise, established by the federal executive body responsible for the development and implementation of state policy and legal regulation in the field of social protection of the population, points;

n is the ordinal number of the organization of the corresponding social sphere;

The number of organizations in the relevant sector of the social sphere in the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, in respect of which an independent assessment of the quality of the provision of services by organizations in the social sphere was carried out in the reporting year, units.

9. The indicator "Results of an independent assessment of the quality of services provided by social organizations" is submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation by August 15 of the year following the reporting year, annually, starting from 2020.

Document overview

The Government of the Russian Federation has approved methods for calculating 9 new indicators to assess the effectiveness of the activities of regional authorities.

Rosstat will calculate:

The ratio of the average per capita income of the population minus the amounts of mandatory payments and payments for housing and communal services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services;

The ratio of the average per capita expenditures of the population on payment for utility services to the cost of a fixed set of basic consumer goods and services;

The volume of investments in fixed assets (except for the federal budget, investments in the extractive industries) per capita.

The Ministry of Construction of Russia will calculate:

Housing affordability ratio (the number of years it takes for a family of 3 people to purchase an apartment of 54 sq. M, taking into account the average annual gross income of the family);

The number of days with a disruption in the supply of water, heat and electricity, on average, per 1 inhabitant.

Rosprirodnadzor will calculate the share of disposed municipal solid waste in their total volume.

Rosvodresursy will calculate the share of standard wastewater treated in their total volume.

The Ministry of Transport of Russia will calculate the density of the network of public roads (except for federal roads) that meet the regulatory requirements for transport and operational indicators.

The Ministry of Labor of Russia will calculate the results of an independent assessment of the quality of service delivery by social organizations.

The new indicators will be used in assessing the effectiveness of activities to increase the level of socio-economic development from 2020, and in assessing the achievement of high rates of increasing the economic (tax) potential of territories - from 2021.